How You Can Combine a Housing Disrepair Claim with Personal Injury Claims: An Educational Guide For Claimants

Sharing is caring!

If your landlord has failed to carry out essential repairs and you’ve suffered an illness or injury as a result, you may be able to pursue both a Housing Disrepair Claim and a Personal Injury Claim. While these claims are closely connected, they compensate for different types of loss and can often be brought together.

Many tenants are unaware that living with damp, mould, leaks, faulty heating or other disrepair doesn’t just give rise to a claim for the condition of the property itself. If those issues have caused physical injuries, respiratory illnesses, or psychological harm, you may also be entitled to claim personal injury compensation.

In this guide, we explain what a housing disrepair claim is, when a personal injury claim may also arise, how the two claims can be combined, and the types of compensation you could be entitled to receive.

What Is a Housing Disrepair Claim?

A housing disrepair claim is a legal claim brought against a landlord who has failed to carry out repairs that they are legally responsible for.

Under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, landlords have a duty to keep certain parts of rented properties in good repair, including:

• Structural walls and roofs
• Windows and doors
• Heating systems
• Plumbing and drainage
• Electrical installations
• Hot water systems

If your landlord knows (or should reasonably know) about a repair problem and fails to fix it within a reasonable time, they may be in breach of their legal obligations.

Common examples include:

• Persistent damp and mould
• Roof leaks
• Water ingress
• Faulty heating
• Dangerous electrics
• Broken windows
• Defective flooring or stairs
• Pest infestations caused by disrepair

Housing disrepair claims usually seek compensation for:

• Living in poor conditions
• Damage to belongings
• Inconvenience and distress
• Reduced enjoyment of your home
• Financial losses caused by the disrepair

In many cases, the landlord can also be ordered to complete the outstanding repairs.

Can Housing Disrepair Cause Personal Injury?

Yes.

Sometimes housing disrepair doesn’t just make a property unpleasant it causes genuine physical or psychological harm.

Examples include:

• Asthma made worse by mould
• Respiratory illnesses caused by damp
• Slips and falls caused by leaking water
• Broken bones from defective stairs
• Burns from faulty boilers
• Electric shocks
• Carbon monoxide poisoning
• Mental health conditions arising from prolonged unsafe living conditions

When this happens, you may have a personal injury claim in addition to your housing disrepair claim.

Can You Make Both Claims?

In many situations, yes.

A housing disrepair claim and a personal injury claim compensate for different losses.

A housing disrepair claim focuses on the condition of the property and the impact the disrepair has had on your enjoyment of your home.

A personal injury claim focuses on the injury or illness you have suffered because of the landlord’s negligence.

Although the claims are closely connected, they are legally distinct.

Many solicitors pursue them together where appropriate, allowing all aspects of your losses to be considered.

Example

Imagine your landlord ignores repeated reports of severe mould for over a year.

As a result:

• Your clothing and furniture become damaged.
• You cannot safely use one of your bedrooms.
• Your child develops worsening asthma requiring hospital treatment.

In this scenario you may have:

A Housing Disrepair Claim

• Compensation for living in poor conditions.
• Damaged belongings.
• Loss of enjoyment of your home.

A Personal Injury Claim

• Compensation for your child’s illness.
• Pain and suffering.
• Medical expenses.
• Future treatment costs where appropriate.

These claims arise from the same events but compensate different losses.

What Compensation Could You Receive?

Every claim is different, and compensation depends on the severity of the disrepair and the extent of any injuries.

Housing Disrepair Compensation

Housing disrepair compensation often reflects:

• The seriousness of the defects.
• How long they lasted.
• The effect on daily life.
• Damage to possessions.
• Any financial losses.

In many successful claims, compensation can range from several hundred pounds to many thousands of pounds depending on the circumstances.

Personal Injury Compensation

Personal injury compensation is assessed differently.

It considers:

• Pain and suffering.
• Loss of amenity.
• Any psychological injuries.
• Financial losses.
• Future care needs.
• Loss of earnings where applicable.

Medical evidence is usually required to value the injuries suffered accurately.

Real Examples from the Courts

The value of housing disrepair and personal injury claims varies significantly depending on the evidence and the individual circumstances.

Some notable examples include:

Wallace v Manchester City Council [1998]

The Court of Appeal confirmed that tenants can recover damages for discomfort, inconvenience and loss of enjoyment caused by housing disrepair. The decision remains an important authority on how damages are assessed where a landlord fails to carry out repairs.

English Churches Housing Group v Shine [2004]

The court considered compensation arising from prolonged housing disrepair affecting a tenant’s enjoyment of their property, reinforcing principles used when assessing general damages in housing disrepair cases.

Rogerson v Bolsover District Council [2019]

The court examined a landlord’s liability following a tenant’s injury caused by defects within rented accommodation, highlighting that landlords may face liability where failures to repair create foreseeable risks of personal injury.

How Are Housing Disrepair Damages Calculated?

Courts often consider:

• The length of time the disrepair existed.
• Which rooms were affected.
• Whether the property became partly unusable.
• The severity of the defects.
• The impact on family life.

In many cases, housing disrepair damages are assessed as a percentage of the rent paid during the period of disrepair.

More serious cases involving multiple unusable rooms can result in substantially higher awards.

Time Limits

Different limitation periods may apply depending on the type of claim.

Generally:

• Housing disrepair claims should usually be started within six years of the breach of repairing obligations.
• Personal injury claims are generally subject to a three-year limitation period from the date of the injury or the date you became aware that your injury was linked to the landlord’s negligence.

As limitation rules can be complex, it is advisable to seek legal advice promptly.

What Evidence Will Help Your Claim?

Strong evidence often makes a significant difference.

Useful evidence includes:

• Photographs of the disrepair
• Videos
• Emails to your landlord
• Repair reports
• GP or hospital records
• Independent survey reports
• Witness statements
• Rent statements
• Receipts for damaged belongings

Keeping a timeline of events can also help establish how long the issues persisted.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I claim if my landlord eventually repaired the problem?

Yes. If you suffered loss or injury before the repairs were completed after making previous reasonable requests, you may still have a claim.

Can council tenants make housing disrepair claims?

Yes. Local authorities, housing associations and private landlords all have legal repairing obligations.

Can mould alone justify a claim?

Potentially, yes. Persistent damp and mould that affects your health or substantially interferes with your use of your home may give rise to a claim, depending on the facts and the landlord’s responsibilities.

Will making a claim affect my tenancy?

Landlords are generally prohibited from retaliating against tenants for asserting their legal rights. If you are concerned about your position, legal advice should be sought at an early stage.